Last night I went to bed heavy with the news that Troy Davis had been executed by the State of Georgia. If you don’t know who he is, or why this is significant, read these 10 reasons why he shouldn’t have been executed. That and a Google search of his name should get you up to speed.
This issue, like so many others, has already fallen upon political lines: conservatives are pro-death penalty and liberals are anti-death penalty, therefore everyone has to take their chosen political side in the debate. I think that is terrible for us as a country, and terrible for people like Troy Davis who may have been convicted unjustly and deserved to at least have a retrial before he was executed. The problem, from my perspective, is simple.
Justice as an idea is not an idea for political parties to claim.
We all desire to see criminals brought to justice. And we all want to see innocent people enjoy their life. And therefore, in situations like this, the issue ought not be the death penalty itself, but the significant flaws in our justice system. The fact that not even the highest court in the land was willing to stay the execution and give Troy Davis another chance is, for me, really disheartening.
I’m willing to engage in fruitful discussions of what justice looks like, but first we as Americans must come to grips with the fact that our justice system is broken. It doesn’t take long to build a case for the injustice that is currently present in American courts and prisons – and to recognize that Troy Davis is not the only one suffering because of this.
Spend some time looking up statistics. The number of people currently in prison in America. The racial breakdown of the prison population. The amount of first time offenders who become second time offenders.
The problems are deeper though. In California, until Governor Brown, it was extremely hard to get parole granted because the governor had to approve it, and what governor wants to risk setting free someone who will commit another crime? Or read the book Zeitoun to find out how the PATRIOT act has given the government sweeping powers to hold people without cause or due process.
If reading and researching is too hard, try listening. Here’s a few This American Life episodes that tell the stories of people who have struggled with the injustice of our current system. Perfect Evidence, an episode about the rise of DNA evidence and how it is showing not just criminal wrongdoing, but wrongdoing on the parts of police and law enforcement officials. Sentencing, on the issue of how to handle first-time drug offenders. And most recent of all, Very Tough Love, a terrible episode about a drug court in Georgia that may be stepping way beyond its power.
Want to watch a film? You could do worse than to watch Erroll Morris’ classic documentary The Thin Blue Line about Randall Adams, a man who was wrongly convicted of murder. Morris’ documentary is actually the reason he was given a retrial, had the film not been made, it is likely Adams would have been executed.
There is so much more information out there, all you have to do is look. You could do worse than to start with The Innocent Project, a non-profit dedicated to helping people who were wrongly convicted. Please don’t keep yourself in the dark.
The death penalty is a touchy issue, but justice in general shouldn’t be. The American Justice system needs a lot of work. Troy Davis is just the most recent and most visible example of this.
Update: Longform.org and Slate Magazine have collected some great longform articles relating to the death penalty. If you are trying to study up, this is also a great resource.
